Should Hanumān speak Sanskrit to Sītā?
अहं ह्य् अतितनुश् चैव वानरश् च विशेषतः ।
वाचं चोदाहरिष्यामि मानुषीम् इह संस्कृताम् ॥
यदि वाचं प्रदास्यामि द्विजातिर् इव संस्कृताम् ।
रावणं मन्यमाना मां सीता भीता भविष्यति ॥
अवश्यम् एव वक्तव्यं मानुषं वाक्यम् अर्थवत् ।
मया सान्त्वयितुं शक्या नान्यथेयम् अनिन्दिता ॥
ahaṃ hy atitanuś caiva vānaraś ca viśeṣataḥ |
vācaṃ codāhariṣyāmi mānuṣīm iha saṃskṛtām ||
yadi vācaṃ pradāsyāmi dvijātir iva saṃskṛtām |
rāvaṇaṃ manyamānā māṃ sītā bhītā bhaviṣyati ||
avaśyam eva vaktavyaṃ mānuṣaṃ vākyam arthavat |
mayā sāntvayituṃ śakyā nānyatheyam aninditā ||
Translation
"I am very small, and a monkey besides; but I shall speak a human language, a refined one. Yet if I speak refined speech like a brahmin, Sītā will take me for Rāvaṇa and be frightened. So I must speak ordinary human words that make sense; otherwise I cannot comfort this blameless lady."
Meaning
The passage is a favourite of historians of language because it shows an epic poet aware of different registers of speech: polished and priestly on one side, plain and human on the other. Commentators still debate whether Hanumān finally speaks "plain Sanskrit" or a vernacular.
It is also good psychology: before he says a word, Hanumān thinks about how his listener will feel.
Word by word · 13 words
| Devanagari | IAST | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| अतितनुः | atitanuḥ | very small (nom. sg. m.) |
| वानरः | vānaraḥ | a monkey (nom. sg. m.) |
| विशेषतः | viśeṣataḥ | above all |
| वाचम् | vācam | speech, language (acc. sg. f.) |
| उदाहरिष्यामि | udāhariṣyāmi | I shall utter (future 1st sg. of ud + ā + √hṛ) |
| मानुषीम् | mānuṣīm | human (acc. sg. f.) |
| संस्कृताम् | saṃskṛtām | refined, polished (acc. sg. f., past participle of sam + √kṛ) |
| द्विजातिः इव | dvijātiḥ iva | like a brahmin, "twice-born" |
| मन्यमाना | manyamānā | thinking (me to be) (pres. participle middle, nom. sg. f.) |
| भीता | bhītā | frightened (nom. sg. f.) |
| मानुषम् वाक्यम् | mānuṣam vākyam | ordinary human speech |
| अर्थवत् | arthavat | meaningful, to the point |
| सान्त्वयितुम् | sāntvayitum | to comfort (infinitive) |
Pronunciation
ahaṃ hyatitanuścaiva vānaraśca viśeṣataḥ |
vācaṃ codāhariṣyāmi mānuṣīmiha saṃskṛtām ||
- saṃskṛtām: the nasal before s, then s-k cluster and the vowel ṛ: saṃs-kṛ-tām.
- codāhariṣyāmi = ca + udāhariṣyāmi: co-dā-ha-riṣ-yā-mi.
- ṛ is a vowel, a short syllabic r (like the "ri" in "rhythm" said quickly): mṛ-tyu, not mar-tyu.
- A final visarga ḥ is a soft "h" breath that echoes the vowel before it: namaḥ sounds like "nama-ha" (lightly).